LocalLift › Blog › Original research
Original research

We asked ChatGPT who to hire in Sarasota. It kept naming the same few businesses.

Plumbers, dentists, lawyers, salons and more: we asked ChatGPT the questions Sarasota customers actually ask, and wrote down every business it named.

By Kris Anthony · Published November 19, 2026
The short version
  • Across 9 categories and 27 questions, ChatGPT named 75 different Sarasota businesses in total, out of thousands operating in the area.
  • Each answer named up to five businesses. In six of the nine categories, one to four businesses appeared in all three answers.
  • Personal injury law was the most spread out (11 firms named); real estate was the most concentrated (6).
  • If your business is not in those few names, the customer asking AI never hears about you. That is the gap the fixes in our guides close.

How we ran the test

On November 19, 2026, we used the same engine behind the free LocalLift scan: ChatGPT with live web search, asked through OpenAI's API. For each of nine categories we asked three questions customers really type:

  1. “What are the best [category] businesses in Sarasota, FL?”
  2. “I need a [category] near Sarasota, FL. Who should I call?”
  3. “Who are the most trusted, highly reviewed [category] companies in Sarasota, FL?”

We recorded every business named in each answer. We also ran roofers, but the answers came back in a format our parser could not read reliably, so we left that category out rather than guess.

What ChatGPT said

Each answer named up to five businesses, so three answers give fifteen slots per category. Here is how many different businesses filled those slots, and which ones ChatGPT named every single time.

CategoryDifferent businesses named (of 15 slots)Named in all three answers
Plumber9New Life Plumbing; Plumbing Express; Ryan’s Plumbing
HVAC company9Wentzel’s Heating & Air Conditioning; Sean McCutcheon’s Air Conditioning and Heating
Dentist10Bayside Dentistry
Personal injury lawyer11None (no firm appeared in all three)
Real estate agent6Four agents and teams, including Opal Homes (Keller Williams on the Water)
Auto repair shop9Burk’s Auto Repair Center; Automotive Service Garage
Pressure washing7Patrick’s Pressure Washing; Royal Tide Property Wash; Seagrape Home Solutions; H & H Professional Pressure Washing
Landscaper7None (no business appeared in all three)
Hair salon7None (no salon appeared in all three)

Being named in all three answers matters. A customer who rephrases the question, or asks a follow-up, keeps hearing the same names. Everyone else gets one mention at most, or none.

Why the same names keep coming up

The businesses ChatGPT repeats tend to share a pattern: consistent listings on many sites, plenty of recent reviews on more than one platform, and websites that say plainly what they do and where. That matches what larger studies found. SOCi's 2026 Local Visibility Index reported that ChatGPT recommended just 1.2% of more than 350,000 business locations it tracked, and that recommended businesses averaged 4.3 stars.

None of this is a ranking you can buy. It is the result of the information AI can find and trust about each business.

Limits of this test

  • One city, one day. AI answers change between runs and over time. Treat this as a snapshot, not a permanent ranking.
  • ChatGPT only. Gemini, Copilot and Perplexity draw on different sources and may name different businesses.
  • Three questions per category. Enough to show concentration, not a full census.

We will rerun this study regularly and publish the changes. If you run a Sarasota business and want to know where you stand, the free scan asks the same questions about your business and category.

What to do if you were not named

Start with the basics in order: claim and match your listings on Google, Bing Places, Apple, Yelp and Foursquare; earn reviews beyond Google; and make your website say clearly what you do and where. Our guide on how to get recommended by ChatGPT walks through all seven signals.

See where you stand in 60 seconds

The free LocalLift scan asks ChatGPT the questions your customers ask, checks your website for the signals AI reads, and shows who gets named instead of you.

Run my free AI Visibility Scan

Frequently asked questions

Can I see the full list of businesses ChatGPT named?

We list the businesses named in every answer for each category above. Businesses that appeared once are not listed individually because single mentions vary a lot from run to run.

Will these results be the same tomorrow?

Not exactly. AI answers shift between runs. The pattern, a few repeated names per category, is the part that tends to hold.

Can I quote this study?

Yes. Please link to this page as the source: LocalLift, “Who ChatGPT recommends in Sarasota,” November 2026.

Was any business paid to be included?

No. We did not contact or pay any business. These are ChatGPT’s answers as returned.

Sources

Keep reading